Expedition Expedition Navigation Software

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?



7/12/2016 7:45 am  #1


Routing for low wind speeds

I'm getting a routing solution with low wind speeds TWA<6k but my polars have no entries <6k.

How does this work?  This is a race critical question since the start is less than 4 days off for the Mackinac race this year.

TIA, pjl

 

7/12/2016 10:59 am  #2


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

With TWS<6 knots its a gamble anyway.
But I think Exp takes your 6k polar if you haven't defined a polar for e.g. 4 knots.

 

7/12/2016 1:17 pm  #3


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

I would suspect that the polar speed is obtained the same way that any other polar speed is obtained for which there is not a discrete TWS value in the polar table (for example, at 7 kts TWS). The VPP that predicated the polar table has the information although it may not be visible in the curves depicted in the polar diagram.

Try this to reveal the polar data: bring up your polars in Exp, click "Edit", click "Upwind", position your cursor in the 4 kt TWS position on the bottom axis of the graph, walk the cursor vertically up the graph until you intersect the BSP curve (or the VMG curve or the TWA curve). The 3 items of data in the upper left corner that change as you move the cursor are 1) TWS, 2) TWA and 3) BSP or VMG (depending where you place the cursor). Be careful not to do any clicking or dragging or you will alter your polar; should you mistakenly do this, simply do not save the changes when you exit the "Edit" function.  

Good Luck in the PH-Mac   

 

7/12/2016 1:46 pm  #4


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

Exp fits a nice curve between the tws values in the polar.
Below the lowest, it just interpolates to zero.​
You can see this in edit polars if you select up or down targets

Last edited by Nick (7/12/2016 1:46 pm)

 

7/12/2016 6:53 pm  #5


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

Nick
Are you saying that below 6 knots, where that is your lowest TWS in polars, target BSP will be zero, or that Exp extends the curve below 6 knots, so e.g. in TWS 4 knots , target BSP might be 2 knots?

 

7/12/2016 7:35 pm  #6


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

It is a linear interpolation between the lowest value (in this case, 6kt) and zero. Have a look at the edit polars plot for a visual

 

7/13/2016 8:09 am  #7


Re: Routing for low wind speeds

Good comments, but I need more soak and study time to appreciate the finesse here.  I tried first to guesstimate a 4K polar which led me to the views mentioned in this string, which showed me an approach to improve my original guesses to get a more logical array.  One conclusion after all this fiddling is that the present algorithm that does what Nick states is probably as good a guess as any for the purpose at hand.  Light air being what it is!

     Thread Starter
 

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum


Interested in advertising here? Over a thousand active navigators and Expedition users visit this forum. Click here to contact the administrator.